Eff you, coronavirus, we can sew our way to eliminating you
Get link
Facebook
X
Pinterest
Email
Other Apps
Six layers of satin - 65% filtration
Mid 2021 update: High thread count cotton and/or multi-layer polyester satin isn't a good choice for high filtration masks. They're not breathable enough at mid filtration performance. And additional layering to get to hight filtration still only decreases breathability further. With that they get hot and uncomfortable as well as giving your chest muscles a good workout.
1. Take a single piece of 85cm x 33cm satin. No cotton needed.
2. fold it in half, sew it minimally to make that feel like a double thick 42.4cm x 33cm piece.
Verdict - breathable enough for a high filtration mask. This was 15 mins sewing time (no including making lengths of strap from sheets too).
Reminder on design features:
1. washable/dryable 2. high filtration (good self-protection as well as protection for others) 3. breathable
Turns out that six months of work designing and sewing in "stiffeners" to boost breathability of varieties incorporating high-thread count (400+) cotton wasn't needed: satin on its own will do it if six layers thick AND you stitch the layers togethers to make some minimal stiffness.
Here's the offcuts from the finished mask:
Filtration effectiveness figures
Previously shared figures for this material apply.
A chart from there, note the green line near the top:
My percentages are kitchen-sink determined with a friend in Vermont who had the machinery to test.
Update: Aaron Collins tests - Jan 10th, 2021
With a test particle size of 63nm (smaller than the viron itself), the 6-layer mask is 66% protective after the first wash & dry (55% before that). When Aaron did a second test with the edges pressed onto his face, the filtration was the same. Meaning for him at least the mask as supplied was a good fit. Look at the graph above. With Aaron's datapoint:
Our six layers of satin is now dotted blue - 0.063 µm the leftmost datapoint.
It's no secret that cloth masks increasingly lose filtration effectiveness below 1 µm particle size.
Satin in multilayer configuration was also tested in Konda et al 2020. Only two layers though, and you'd have use some formulas to work out what protection you'd get with six layers. The result of that formula for six layers of satin (per Konda's results) would be near enough 100% protection for the important particle sizes. There are criticisms of Konda's methods online as yielding results that are too high, so I going to discount that the 100% possibility and use my Vermont friends more conservative 93% (ish) figures.
I have been told off in social media for saying "satin" as some people might that thank includes silk or sateen (cotton). I'm on about the pure polyester variant with NO lycra/spandex. Also that is cheap satin that'd be used in bedding rather than garments or fashion.
Konda et al's study has been criticized for having too optimistic protection percentages.
Comments
Post a Comment