Aaron's video test of my three masks - shortest clip
Citizen Scientist, Aaron Collins (@masknerd on Twitter) tested three more washable masks of mine.
- Four layers of spunbond polypropylene (38 gsm Smart-fab), with one outer layer of 180 TPI of poly-cotton
- Same, but with eight layers of the spunbond polypropylene (SBPP)
- Same, but with twelve layers of the SBPP Aaron’s two hour livestream: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=73JWxBXqIR0
What follows is just my masks from the middle of his live stream. Results:
Four layers SBPP (152 gsm) + one of 180 TPI polycotton
Filtration Efficiency: 73.0% Time to Max Breath @ 0.25" H20: 2.23 Pressure Drop: 0.13 Quality Factor: 10.2Eight layers SBPP (304 gsm) + one of 180 TPI polycotton
Filtration Efficiency: 84.9% Time to Max Breath @ 0.25" H20: 3.02 Pressure Drop: 0.17 Quality Factor: 10.9Twelve layers SBPP (456 gsm) + one of 180 TPI polycotton
Filtration Efficiency: 85.7% Time to Max Breath @ 0.25" H20: 3.84 Pressure Drop: 0.22 Quality Factor: 8.7Aaron talks of early fabrication studies, some differences between melt blown and spunbond PP,
breathability, pressure drop, a few cents per mask cost, suitability for the developing world.
One key thing Aaron says:
“we should not have wasted our time with cotton”
Previously, Aaron had tested a mask made from six layers of satin (polyester) in the same design as here. He tested that one and it came in at 55% filtration effectiveness. A couple of weeks later he had washed it and dried it and tested it again at 65% filtration effectiveness. Many fabrics will be better after one wash.
Aaron's spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1M0mdNLpTWEGcluK6hh5LjjcFixwmOG853Ff45d3O-L0/edit#gid=1976839763
All of mine are in there as "Rag Mask". You should assume you'd get the same filtration effectiveness for any 3D-style pattern made with the same gsm of SBPP that is a good fit.
Comments
Post a Comment